Extraterritoriality reality?

Legislators and regulators all around the globe are rushing to meet the G20 commitment of shifting all standardised OTC derivative contracts onto exchanges or electronic trading platforms. Naturally, every country is trying to clean up its own backyard before looking across the fence at its neighbour’s. The disadvantage of this approach is that country-specific rules might not necessarily harmonise with each other. Exactly this issue was escalated in the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s (CFTC) Global Markets Advisory Committee (GMAC) meeting on 7th November. Representatives from the European Union, China, Japan and Canada, among others, aired their criticism of the CFTC Cross-Border Guidance relating to the US swap markets regulation.

Swap markets are truly global. As Robert Cook, director of the SEC’s trading and markets division, explains most credit default swap (CDS) transactions have an international component. Data from the Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation’s Trade Information Warehouse shows that only a small percentage of CDS trades are transacted between two wholly US entities. The current CFTC Cross-Border Guidance acknowledges the global nature of the market by extending its own reach significantly beyond US borders to include any swap that has a direct and significant impact on the US economy. CFTC Chairman Gary Gensler argues that this wide definition is necessary because extraterritorial risks can flow rapidly back to US shores in times of crisis. However, international regulators and industry representatives fear that this statute will invite other countries to respond tit-for-tat and create massive overlapping regulation, not to mention confusion.

I couldn’t help but wonder: is our new reality one of continuous nightmares of extraterritoriality-related problems? Should I stop eating hamburgers and start to order fish & chips because no one is sure of the legal implications of my preference for American beef?

Fortunately, a few days after the GMAC meeting, CFTC Commissioner Scott D. O’Malia gave a speech outlining why he believes that the published Cross-Border Guidance does not live up to the job of good regulation and why he would rather do it all over again. He criticises the lack of a formal rule-making process, the regulatory overreach and the definition of US persons. Finally, he stresses the importance of a clear concept of “substituted compliance” that would allow multiple regional regulations to live alongside each other.

The reality is that the CFTC is as divided on extraterritoriality as any other regulator and the quest for good regulation will continue around the world. Swap markets are global and interconnected. The only way regulators can deal with that is by harmonising and eliminating redundancy and inconsistency.

Leave A Comment

Copyright © 2019 Fidessa Group Holdings Limited. All rights reserved.

The information contained within this website is provided for informational purposes only. Fidessa will use reasonable care to ensure that information is accurate at the time it is made available, and for the duration that it remains on the site. The information may be changed by Fidessa at any time without notice. We also reserve the right to close the website at any time. No representation or warranty, expressed or implied, is given on behalf of Fidessa or any of its respective directors, employees, agents, or advisers as to the accuracy or completeness of the information or opinions contained herein or its suitability for any purpose and, save in the case of fraud, all liability for direct, indirect, special, consequential or other loss or damages of whatever kind that may arise from use of the website is hereby excluded to the fullest extent permitted by law. Any decisions you make based on the information in this website are your sole responsibility and information on the website should not be relied upon in connection with any investment decision.

The copyright of this website belongs to Fidessa. All other intellectual property rights are reserved.

Reproduction or redistribution of this information is prohibited except with written permission from Fidessa.